Times Square, a dazzling nexus of entertainment and commerce in the heart of New York City, draws millions of visitors each year. The area pulsates with energy, its towering screens and Broadway marquees creating an unforgettable spectacle. While the bright lights and bustling atmosphere are undeniably captivating, the culinary landscape of Times Square can be a bit more challenging to navigate. Many a tourist has fallen prey to the lure of mediocre chain restaurants that populate the area. However, fear not, discerning traveler! Beneath the surface of the tourist traps lies a vibrant and diverse dining scene, offering a delectable escape for those seeking authentic and memorable culinary experiences.
This guide unveils 15 of the best restaurants in Times Square, each offering a unique flavor and atmosphere, far removed from the predictable fare of national chains. From celebrity-chef-helmed Italian havens to authentic Sichuan spice palaces, these establishments promise a gastronomic journey that will elevate your Times Square experience. So, whether you’re catching a Broadway show, soaking in the iconic sights, or simply seeking a respite from the crowds, prepare to discover the culinary gems that make Times Square a destination for more than just spectacle.
1. Becco Restaurant: A Pasta Paradise
- Address: 355 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-397-7597
- Cuisine: Italian
Becco Restaurant, co-owned by the celebrated chef Lidia Bastianich, is a haven for pasta lovers. This popular establishment is renowned for its "all you can eat" pasta special, a nightly offering featuring an antipasto or salad followed by three distinct pasta preparations. While spotting Lidia herself might be a matter of luck, the guarantee of a satisfying and authentic Italian meal is virtually assured. The ambiance is warm and inviting, reminiscent of a classic Italian trattoria. The popularity of Becco means reservations are highly recommended to avoid lengthy waits. The all-day pasta special is priced at $29.95, and the restaurant boasts an impressive wine list with bottles available for $35, making it an excellent value for the quality and experience.
2. Carmine’s Restaurant: Family-Style Feast
- Address: 200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-221-3800
- Cuisine: Italian-American
Since 1992, Carmine’s has been a Times Square institution, serving up generous portions of classic Italian-American cuisine in a vibrant, family-style setting. The restaurant’s atmosphere is boisterous and convivial, perfect for large groups and celebratory gatherings. The menu features a wide array of familiar favorites, from pasta dishes laden with rich sauces to hearty meat entrees, all designed for sharing. The portions are undeniably substantial, making Carmine’s an excellent choice for those seeking a satisfying and communal dining experience. Dishes are priced at $28 or more, reflecting the generous serving sizes.
3. Churrascaria Plataforma: A Brazilian Meat Lover’s Dream
- Address: 316 W 49th St, New York, NY 10019
- Phone: +1 212-245-0505
- Cuisine: Brazilian
For those with a hearty appetite and a penchant for grilled meats, Churrascaria Plataforma offers a truly unforgettable dining experience. This Brazilian rodizio-style restaurant features a prix-fixe menu that includes an endless parade of succulent grilled meats, carved tableside by skilled gauchos. The ambiance is festive and lively, with a vibrant energy that adds to the overall experience. In addition to the meat offerings, the restaurant boasts an extensive salad bar, providing a refreshing counterpoint to the richness of the meats. Diners utilize a double-sided green/red chip to signal their desire for more meat, ensuring a constant flow of culinary delights. The prix-fixe meal is priced at $45 per person on weekdays and $49 on weekends, excluding dessert.
4. John’s Pizzeria: Coal-Oven Perfection
- Address: 260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-391-7560
- Cuisine: Pizza, Italian
Housed within a deconsecrated church, John’s Pizzeria offers a unique and atmospheric setting for enjoying some of the best pizza in Times Square. This outpost of the famed Greenwich Village original is renowned for its coal-oven pizzas, characterized by their crispy crusts and smoky flavor. The ambiance is both historic and inviting, with high ceilings and stained-glass windows adding to the overall charm. In addition to pizza, John’s also serves up solid Italian sandwiches and entrees. Pizzas are available in small and large sizes only, with whole-wheat and gluten-free options to cater to various dietary needs.
5. Shake Shack: A Modern Burger Classic
- Address: 691 8th Ave, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 646-435-0135
- Cuisine: Burgers, Fast Casual
While Shake Shack’s original location resides in Madison Square Park, its Theater District outpost offers a convenient and vibrant option for burger lovers in Times Square. This modern burger joint is known for its high-quality ingredients and delicious menu, featuring signature Shack Burgers, crispy fries, and flat-grilled Chicago hot dogs. The restaurant’s floor-to-ceiling windows provide ample opportunities for people-watching, adding to the lively atmosphere. As a quick-service establishment, Shake Shack does not accept reservations, so be prepared for potential lines and a bit of a hunt for available seating during peak hours.
6. Sushi of Gari: An Artistic Sushi Experience
- Address: 347 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-957-0046
- Cuisine: Sushi
Sushi connoisseurs will appreciate the sophisticated preparations at Sushi of Gari’s Theater District location. Gari is best known for high-quality fish and special sauces that dress the nigiri, so don’t make the mistake of dousing your sushi in soy sauce or you’ll miss out on what makes this restaurant special.
7. Virgil’s: Southern BBQ in the City
- Address: 152 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-921-9494
- Cuisine: Barbecue
Virgil’s offers some of New York City’s best barbecue, including Memphis ribs and Carolina pulled pork. Portions are generous and they have a full bar with signature drinks. Reservations are recommended, and you should allow plenty of time if you’re going to a show afterward as service can be slow.
8. Wu Liang Ye: Sichuan Spice Sensation
- Address: 36 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-398-2308
- Cuisine: Sichuan
Wu Liang Ye is regarded as one of Manhattan’s best Sichuan restaurants, offering Sichuan dumplings, Kung Pao chicken, and cold sesame noodles as some of the most popular dishes. Be warned, though, that Sichuan dishes tend to be hot.
9. Lillie’s Victorian Establishment: A Step Back in Time
- Address: 13 E 17th St, New York, NY 10003
- Phone: +1 212-337-1970
- Cuisine: Gastropub
Harkening back to one of the great gin palaces of Northern Ireland and England, Lillie’s Victorian Establishment is furnished in antique décor imported from Northern Ireland—including the marble bar, which originally lived in a Victorian mansion in Belfast.
10. R Lounge at Two Times Square: Views and Bites
- Address: 714 7th Ave, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-261-5114
- Cuisine: Bar Bites, Cocktails
Located inside the Renaissance New York Times Square Hotel, the R Lounge restaurant offers gourmet cuisine and stunning views over the bustling Times Square streets.
11. Toloache: A Taste of Mexico City
- Address: 251 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019
- Phone: +1 212-581-1818
- Cuisine: Mexican
Chef and owner Julian Medina brings a taste of Mexico City and the best in Latin cuisine to the heart of Times Square in the traditional Mexican restaurant known as Toloache.
12. Osteria al Doge: Venetian Elegance
- Address: 142 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 212-944-3643
- Cuisine: Italian
This upscale Italian restaurant offers homemade pasta, thin-crusted pizza, and meat and pesci (fish) entrées at relatively reasonable prices, especially for Times Square.
13. Junior’s Times Square: Cheesecake Heaven
- Address: Multiple Locations in Times Square
- Cuisine: Diner, Cheesecake
Although Junior’s is a tourist attraction, it’s also a pretty great place to get a slice of New York cheesecake and a pretty great meal.
14. Butter: Upscale Comfort
- Address: 70 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
- Phone: +1 646-719-1364
- Cuisine: American, Comfort Food
The chic and stylish Butter restaurant offers an upscale take on typical American comfort foods, paired with craft cocktails.
15. DB Bistro Moderne: French Flair
- Cuisine: French, Bistro
Named after chef and owner Daniel Boulud, DB Bistro offers modern French bistro cuisine with an updated American spin.
